http://appellatelaw-nj.com/
« Achieving Equality in the Courtroom | Main | Charles W. Hokanson Guest Blogger -Anders/Wende Briefs. »
Tuesday
Oct142014

An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin

                The Appellate Section of the Orange County Bar Association recently presented an interview with Justice Ming Chin of the California Supreme Court.  Needless to say, I try to attend these interviews, hoping I can pick up a hint or two about how to prepare briefs or be effective at oral argument.  (Even after all of these years, I am capable of learning.) 

                Justice Chin reminded us that the Supreme Court has a heavy work load and a short attention span, presumably because it has to deal with so many cases.  He said, “Take out all of the excess words in your brief.”  Okay, that sounds simple, but believe me, it is hard work.  Longer is easier, but shorter requires a lot of editing.  While you want to take out “excess” words, you certainly don’t want to throw out the important words. 

                He suggested a short introduction in your brief and to put your best foot forward in the first paragraph.  None of this, “This case arises from . . .”  Get right to the point.  I call it the “T.V. Guide” approach.  That first paragraph can set the tone for everything that follows.  It should make the reader want to read the brief and gives the Court a clear idea about what is being sought and why the author should win. 

                Justice Chin suggests a brief with 2-3 issues only.  He says, “The Court is not going to sift through the brief that attaches everything done below.” 

                While Justice Chin finds oral argument important, it might not be important for the reasons you think.  Going into the hearing, a conference memo has already been prepared and circulated.  It is only after the Court has at least four justices who agree that the matter is even set for oral argument, which offers the justices an opportunity to “fine-tune” the opinion.  Get that, not change its mind, but to fine-tune what the justices already decided.  Justice Chin also remarked that on one occasion, the justices concluded “we got it wrong.”  One occasion! 

                Justice Chin also advised attorneys to have a theme for their appeals.  The attorney should be able to put that theme into one sentence.  He also cautioned attorneys to consider what to wear to court.  He mentioned one example of a female attorney who wore a bunch of bangles on her arm that made noise when her hand touched the lectern.  I don’t even like having my purse sitting on the counsel table. 

 

References (148)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: GNLD tuotteet
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: ps3 games keeps
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: game better
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: ZQuiet Cost
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: abuse.am-kayq.com
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Adolor Uwamu
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: online golf games
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Clothing
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Adolor Uwamu
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: best water filter
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: phil st ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: posture brace
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: phil st ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Imperial Advance
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: phytolyft
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: www.amazon.com
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Native Garcinia
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: UK Models
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: lombok tourplus
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: storage shed
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: storage shed
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Kion Kashefi
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: 312 Marketing
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Amethyst
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Matrixyderm Review
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Createurs de Luxe
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: source web page
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Kion Kashefi
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Dermatrol Review
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Corey Park
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Corey Park
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Adrenapump Reviews
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: townhomes for sale
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Night on the Town
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Refi Pasadena
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: cofelen Reviews
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: bit.ly
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Phil St Ores
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Gta 5 online Hack
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: shortt.me
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: Muscle Rev Xtreme
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: visit my web page
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: headlamp
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: garage tools
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: cat towers
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: pets
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: bio glaciere
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: about us
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: cellulit
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: cellulit
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: agen bola
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: dietetyk
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: pose porte blindé
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    [...]An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON[...]
  • Response
    Response: bmw
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: pinterest
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming Chin - Home - AN APPEAL TO REASON
  • Response
    Response: gta 5 money cheat
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming
  • Response
    Response: 2018 hindi movie
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming
  • Response
    Response: Edit HTML Online
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming
  • Response
    An Afternoon with Justice Ming
  • Response
    Response: Abogados
    I found a great...
  • Response
    I found a great...

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.